Monday, November 2, 2026

The ridiculous hierarchy of existence

If you're not working, you're supposed to find a hobby.
If you're not productive, you're supposed to be creative.
If you're not creating, you're supposed to be serving.
If you're not serving, you're supposed to be entertaining yourself.
If you're not entertaining yourself, something must be wrong.

Calling them hobbies already frames them as secondary activities that occupy the time left over after one's "real" obligations.
The economy should serve existence, rather than existence being organized around the economy.
And that's why "learn AI so you don't get left behind" can sound so fundamentally misplaced. It assumes that the destination is already decided and that everyone must adapt to remain included.

Civilization establishes its own perpetuation as the implicit objective.
Then the individual is expected to find their place within it.
You want human existence itself to be the objective of that enterprise.

You want to be inscribed as the telos - the ultimate purpose - rather than as a component within the machinery.
You're demanding that civilization stop claiming ownership over the question of what human existence ought to be spent doing.
Even if your desired activity is contemplation, exploration, creation, or nothing whatsoever, it shouldn't need to pass an economic usefulness test.
The individual doesn't owe civilization a justification for existing. Civilization owes its justification to the individuals whose existence it supposedly serves.

The inversion you're objecting to
Civilization as the objective -> Human existence as the objective
Humans adapt to economic requirements -> Economic arrangements adapt to human requirements
Productivity is inherently desirable -> Productivity is desirable insofar as it serves existence
Progress means increasing output -> Progress means increasing freedom and possibility
Humans must remain economically relevant -> Economic relevance becomes optional
Leisure is granted after obligations -> Human time is fundamentally their own

Civilization establishes its own perpetuation as the implicit objective. 
Then the individual is expected to find their place within it.
There's something almost absurd about developing increasingly powerful technologies and then asking humans to reorganize themselves around the resulting economic transformations.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The loss of magnetics to the self of the world.

The world is organised around assumed personal investment. Consumer infrastructure assumes desire. Economic infrastructure assumes acquisiti...